Arguably the biggest mystery in the O.J. Simpson case that never got solved is what happened to the murder weapon, a knife. No murder weapon was presented as evidence in the trial, and no proof of its whereabouts has turned up in three decades. And yet, a couple of people interviewed for American Manhunt think they know what happened to it.

O.J. Simpson" that when he dies, he should be buried "with a pair of Isotoner gloves,” after his botched glove demonstration during the 1995 murder trial.

Despite OJ Simpson’s triumphs in professional athletics, his football talents were not what made him a household name. The shocking murder of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend, Ron Goldman,